Elite private higher education: a small but notable sector
These universities are especially important in the changing landscape of global higher education. They are providing new ideas about the organisation, curriculum and even the philosophy of higher education in countries where academic institutions are often very traditional and bureaucratic.
These universities, often supported by substantial philanthropic efforts, have significant resources, and have been able to attract top students and faculty.
The elite private sector is small – perhaps 150 institutions worldwide. The largest number are in the United States, with perhaps half the total, and a few in countries such as Japan and South Korea. Some Latin American countries host top Catholic universities and a few others. But the largest growth area for top private institutions is now the Global South.
Periods of development
There have been several periods of development for these universities. At the end of the 19th century, wealthy American capitalists sponsored newly invented German-style research universities in an effort to build scientific capacity in the United States. Stanford, Chicago and Johns Hopkins, among others, were established and quickly became elite institutions. Waseda and Keio, with similar missions, were founded in Japan.
A few elite private universities were established in the mid-20th century. Examples include the Tecnológico de Monterrey (Monterrey Tec), established in 1943 in Mexico by industrialists. A decade later, the Manipal Academy of Higher Education was founded in India, followed by the Birla Institute of Technology and Science. These pioneering universities now have multiple campuses in their country and are among the best and most innovative national institutions.
In the following decades, additional innovative universities were founded. Symbiosis International University in Pune, India, was established in 1971 as an internationally focused institution, and the Pohang University of Science and Technology (POSTECH) was founded in 1986 in South Korea.
Insper, an independent university in São Paulo, Brazil, focusing on business, economics and (later) engineering was founded in 1987. LUMS University (formerly Lahore University of Management Sciences) in Pakistan, founded in 1984, grew from a management training institution to a comprehensive university. There were a small number of additional universities founded during this period in other countries.
All of these institutions were founded with a different vision from the standard university ethos. All were committed to excellence and all (with the exception of Symbiosis) were established with considerable private resources and thus the ability, similar to Stanford and Chicago in the US, to establish infrastructure, hire highly qualified faculty and appeal to top students within a short time period.
All had strong links with local business and industry. POSTECH was founded by Korea's largest steel company, POSCO, with the goal of providing a rapidly developing Korean economy with both research capacity and educated personnel. Similarly, Monterrey Tec founders saw the need for talent in Mexico’s most important industrial region, and the founders of Manipal had a similar vision in India’s early period of economic growth.
All of these universities share some common characteristics. They have continued to flourish and expand in the half-century or more of their existence. All have expanded their curricular offerings beyond their founding disciplines – and all have become comprehensive universities.
All are non-profit private universities in countries where most of the top institutions are public. They were established with a clear vision and educational focus, have managed to maintain the original mission over time and have focused on teaching quality from the beginning. They offer both students and academics significantly better facilities and working conditions than most academic institutions in their countries.
The 21st century has brought significant new initiatives in private elite higher education. This development is especially notable in India, where the demand for post-secondary education is immense.
India has a very small but highly selective elite public higher education sector (mainly the Indian Institutes of Technology and Indian Institutes of Management and a few universities), and thus there is much demand for high quality higher education from India’s rapidly expanding middle class and a great need to support its expanding and increasingly sophisticated economy.
Several of India’s billionaires and other business leaders are concerned with India’s need for top quality universities and have responded by contributing significant resources to establish new universities with innovative missions.
Examples include OP Jindal Global University, founded in 2009 with funds from a steel tycoon; Shiv Nadar University (which recently opened a second university in Tamil Nadu), with funding from a tech billionaire; and Ashoka University, established by a group of business and tech leaders in 2014. A new start-up, the Jio Institute, heavily funded by the Reliance conglomerate, will soon open.
These institutions boast impressive campuses and offer several postgraduate and doctoral programmes, but so far mainly educate undergraduate students. All have innovative curricula emphasising liberal arts and pay considerable attention to teaching quality.
To date, these new institutions cater mainly to upper middle-class students who might otherwise choose to study abroad, and all, by Indian standards, charge high tuition fees. Their facilities are superior to all but a few public institutions.
There are perhaps an additional dozen or so similar universities in India, representing a tiny part of India’s higher education landscape, but they are quite influential in terms of introducing new ideas about higher education that may influence other universities.
The idea of philanthropically founded, elite private universities seems less common in the rest of the world. Two examples include: Habib University, which largely serves undergraduate students with a liberal arts curriculum and was established in 2012 in Karachi, Pakistan; and Westlake University, a semi-private, graduate-only, research university in Hangzhou, China, founded in 2018, which aims to develop a world-class STEM-oriented curriculum.
The importance of the ‘new model’
These ‘new model’ well-funded, elite private universities are significant additions to the global higher education landscape. Although there are probably under 50 such institutions in the Global South, they are of great importance.
Although each has its own mission, there are some elements that are common to all. Perhaps most crucial, these universities reflect a different model in their organisation, curriculum and ethos from other academic institutions in their environment and thus new ways of thinking about higher education. Among these elements are:
• Financial backing: These universities are, in their national contexts, well-resourced due to their establishment by wealthy individuals or businesses;
• Innovation: The universities represent new ideas about curriculum, teaching, organisation, student affairs and other aspects of academic life;
• Excellent facilities: They have built ‘state of the art’ campuses that are attractive to students and faculty and permit advanced research and scholarship;
• Governance: As private non-profit universities, these universities differ from the public institutions in their countries in their approach to management and governance and are often less influenced by national political pressures and provide a greater degree of academic freedom;
• Highly qualified students and faculty: With ample resources, these universities are able to attract top quality people. Some hire excellent faculty on the international market while others ‘poach’ the best professors from the public universities;
• Local quality and global orientation: By offering education comparable to international standards, these universities may keep many students at home who would otherwise go abroad for study;
• English: Most of these universities use English either as the sole language of instruction and research or as a prominent language;
• Internationalisation: Links, joint research, collaborative degrees and other international initiatives are integral to these institutions. Students are often offered an international opportunity as part of their degree programme.
Most, if not all, of these elite private institutions depend on revenue from student tuition fees – and this determines academic programmes and future directions. Tuition prices tend to be high so students from low-income families cannot attend; diversity is limited.
Many, such as LUMS in Pakistan, have a robust scholarship programme aimed at low-income and rural students, but by and large the new elite universities remain the preserve of wealthy families; indeed, this may be one of their attractions.
Moreover, these universities remain mainly undergraduate institutions and few have become research-intensive universities with large graduate programmes in the traditional disciplines, although some offer highly regarded professional schools in such fields as business and law.
Yet these universities are arguably the best universities in their countries, although at the same time they sometimes benchmark themselves against the top global institutions – a rather high hurdle. And despite the challenges they face, these elite private institutions have brought vitality to an often moribund higher education environment in their country.
Philip G Altbach is research professor and distinguished fellow, Center for International Higher Education, Boston College, United States.